As a performance management tactic, year-end reviews are a valuable tool for promoting employee development and aligning individual tasks with broader company strategy. Research from McKinsey has found that companies that focus on their people’s performance are 4.2 times more likely to outperform their peers.
However, not all annual review initiatives are truly impactful. To reap the benefits of performance reviews, they must be implemented as part of a broader employee recognition program. By providing ongoing, consistent feedback paired with formal year-end assessments, companies can keep employees motivated and on track with organizational objectives.
In this article, we’ll discuss how managers can prepare for year-end reviews as well as the role of constant employee feedback in cultivating a successful workforce.
It’s easy to see performance reviews as just another task on your managerial to-do list. However, these annual conversations provide significant value to employees and employers alike. Here are five key benefits of successful year-end review programs:
When workers receive targeted feedback on their performance, they’re more engaged — and as a result, they perform better and are less likely to leave the company. Research from Gallup found that employees who received feedback on their strengths had a turnover rate of nearly 15% less than those who received zero feedback.
Workers have a basic need to feel appreciated and acknowledged for their efforts. Celebrating workers’ wins and accomplishments from the past year is an effective way to boost their self-confidence, job satisfaction, and overall well-being.
Year-end reviews open up productive conversations around skill development. Managers can nurture career growth by sensitively highlighting worker weaknesses and skill gaps. When delivered tactfully, this constructive feedback caters to employee preferences for on-the-job self-actualization.
Annual reviews are a great benchmark for employee achievement, making it easier for management to evaluate pay raises and promotions objectively. Linking intangible rewards — verbal praise — to tangible, monetary rewards is a powerful recognition practice that improves worker satisfaction.
It’s all too easy for employee efforts to get off track, particularly if job responsibilities aren’t communicated effectively. Year-end reviews are an ideal time to clarify the role and duties of each player in achieving company goals.
Performance reviews are a time to appreciate, guide, and motivate employees. Managers have a lot of ground to cover in these annual sessions, from assessing performance metrics to offering constructive feedback to aligning on future goals. Here are some examples of topics to discuss at your year-end reviews:
What are workers adept at, and what could be improved? When employees have a clear understanding of their strengths and weaknesses, they feel more confident in their abilities and poised to attain professional growth. Take the time to highlight exceptional skills and traits while also discussing areas for improvement in a constructive manner.
Examples:
What were your employees’ biggest wins this year? Celebrating successes is a powerful form of employee recognition that helps workers feel appreciated. Plus, it reinforces desirable behaviors — a win-win for everyone.
Hone in on both obvious and under-the-radar accomplishments like completed projects, certifications, or improvements in customer satisfaction scores.
Examples:
Examples:
Examples:
What challenges did your employees face this year? Effective leaders ensure that their workers feel safe to share any concerns — and then take steps to address these issues.
After you share some positive feedback, ask your employees what they thought of the past year. Keep in mind that most employees will already be a little anxious about the entire situation and may respond with “it was good” or “no complaints.” If that’s the case, you’ll want to proceed with your feedback and revisit the conversation later on.
As you encourage employees to share their honest thoughts, you may consider asking for upward feedback. Companies like HubSpot collect these targeted evaluations of manager performance to improve leadership skills and organizational outcomes.
Examples:
It’s not just employees who fear performance reviews —- managers do too. Vetting worker performance and answering sensitive questions about salaries and promotions can really be daunting.
To overcome pre-performance review anxiety, managers should keep in mind that effective on-the-job feedback is something that most workers actually appreciate. As professor and researcher Nicole Abi-Esber explained in a Harvard Business School study on employee feedback, “People tend to focus on the discomfort of delivering feedback, and underestimate the value of the feedback to the other person, including how much they would appreciate the feedback, and how impactful it would be.”
Here are some ways you can prepare for successful year-end reviews:
Successful year-end reviews require thoughtful preparation on both ends. Give employees a self-assessment form where they can evaluate their performance, consider their professional development goals, and prepare questions for you. Doing so will prevent them from feeling caught off guard and help them feel more confident about the session.
Year-end reviews are most impactful and unbiased when they harness data. Take a close look at your employees’ individual achievements, team interactions, and stakeholder value generated, and gather data for each of these critical dimensions. You’ll want to collect quantifiable data like key performance indicators (KPIs) as well as qualitative data like specific anecdotes that back up measurable impact.
If you use employee recognition software, be sure to reference it for past feedback and performance trends.
Ineffective feedback is demoralizing and harmful rather than productive and appreciated. To keep feedback constructive, keep it future-focused and provide concrete examples. As Gallup consultant Denise McLain explains, “Managers can address shortcomings…by focusing on discernable behaviors rather than employees’ characteristics. They must keep employee development as their goal.”
For example, instead of telling an employee that they lack creativity, mention an instance when abstract brainstorming could have improved outcomes. Then, have a conversation about how you can help them improve this skill.
At least some of your employees will inevitably share concerns or challenge your feedback. To avoid feeling blindsided, take some time to anticipate any sensitive topics that could come up — such as those related to compensation, promotions, or team dynamics — and think about how you can respond supportively and constructively.
Employees want to feel sure that management is always there to support them. Following up with a written summary of your conversation and next steps will send a powerful message that you listen to their feedback and care about their success.
Performance reviews tend to get a bad rep, with one study finding that “only 13% of employees and managers think their organization’s performance appraisal system is useful.”
However, this doesn’t have to be the case. When year-end reviews are approached strategically and part of a broader commitment to professional development, they become an enjoyable and productive experience.
Gallup research has pinpointed three qualities of effective performance reviews: achievement-oriented, fair and accurate, and developmental. Let’s dive into these and other qualities of effective performance reviews:
Successful reviews are forward-focused, with an eye on attaining success rather than penalizing mistakes. Even when it’s necessary to point out errors, it can be done in a way that motivates change rather than incites shame.
Employees can detect bias and errors from a mile away. To prevent discrepancies and inequities, make sure to look at broader trends rather than isolated events. Employee recognition programs are a great way to ensure that employee performance is monitored regularly — which gives managers more data to draw from at year’s end.
Another way to keep performance reviews fair is to reference the worker’s job description. Are your expectations truly in line with the employee’s predetermined schedule and duties? If things are far off track from the original job description, it may be time to update the job description, make accommodations, or offer a promotion.
When performance reviews are all about salary, professional development conversations get swept under the rug. A growing number of companies have separated performance reviews and salary reviews in order to maximize the developmental nature of year-end evaluations. This is a powerful employee retention and satisfaction strategy since employees crave career mentorship on the job.
As Theresa Balsiger, VP of Candidate Relations at Carex Consulting Group explains:
“One change we made years ago was to decouple performance reviews and annual merit increases. When compensation is part of the agenda, very little attention is given to the details of performance. It’s human nature to hear the merit increase, but then have a hard time receiving any additional information.”
When reviews remain positive and growth-oriented, employees feel more confident, supported, and motivated to succeed. Be sure to start the meeting with praise and appreciation before moving on to constructive criticism. And when you do address any shortcomings, do so in a way that demonstrates a clear willingness to support their growth and overcome challenges.
Feedback that’s specific and individualized is not only more impactful, but it comes across as more authentic. When managers give general feedback, it sends the message to employees that their unique contributions are going unnoticed — and that their professional development is not a priority.
As Gallup consultant Denise McLain explains, “The best managers individualize feedback to employees’ natural talents and performance needs. They ensure feedback is relevant to the individual’s contributions and the organization’s purpose — showing employees how their day-to-day efforts influence the big picture.”
Employees want to feel appreciated, recognized, and supported. And while constant employee feedback can engender those feelings, a perfunctory annual meeting simply cannot.
When employee recognition and feedback are limited to once-yearly reviews, employees are left in the dark about their performance for most of the year. The key to overcoming this communication gap is an employee recognition program. When employee recognition is given frequently, it assures workers that they are valued while also fostering ongoing professional development.
As Cindy Kravitz, Director of Strategic Leadership at Stryker, sums it up:
“Think of it like training for a marathon — you wouldn’t wait until race day to evaluate your performance. Instead, you’d track progress regularly, adjust your training based on measurable data, and ensure you’re prepared for the big event.”
Kravitz calls this constant approach to recognition “drive-through feedback,” which, she explains, “involves delivering frequent, concise input during regular one-on-one meetings and immediately following key moments or behaviors. This real-time feedback allows employees to make meaningful adjustments and progress throughout the year, reducing surprises during the final review.”
Employees who receive regular feedback and recognition are happier, more engaged, and more motivated. When top-down communication is wide open and workers are regularly praised in real-time, employee satisfaction gets a measurable boost.
With WorkProud’s employee recognition platform, you can cultivate an environment where year-end reviews are eagerly anticipated rather than feared. Our software includes user-friendly tools for instant praise, reward disbursement, peer-to-peer interactions — and much more. Click here to get started with a free demo!
WorkProud is committed to helping its clients create a unified approach to the employee experience by helping them build cultures of workplace pride. Trusted by millions of users at some of the world’s most recognized employer brands, WorkProud delivers a comprehensive approach to building company cultures that inspire people to be Proud of their Work and Proud of their Company.
Here you will find insights curated for leadership seeking in-depth industry knowledge. Explore comprehensive studies, helpful guides, and expert white papers.
*By selecting “VIEW RESOURCES,” you agree to WorkProud’s Privacy Policy. You may unsubscribe from our emails at any time. Please note when unsubscribing: it may take up to 10 business days for your request to take effect.
